My mother always told me that “the devil you know is usually better than the devil you don’t know.” There is a great deal of wisdom in those words, and I cannot emphasize how true they ring today. When I signed up for this Superior Court gig, I had absolutely no idea what I was getting myself into. Now, that is not to say that I am not enjoying myself. I really do appreciate the experience, the responsibility, and the added variety. Unfortunately, what I was not expecting, was the logistical nightmare that I have now been dealing with for two solid weeks, with no end in sight.
It was bad enough that I started out with a pile of cases that I had never seen before, all of which were patiently waiting for me to actually figure out what was going on in them without so much as a simple primer. Unlike my District Court replacement who had the advantage of…well…me (and I do not mean for that to sound haughty or otherwise egotistical), I have been given no mentorship, no guidance, and no warning of the things to come. I barely even have someone that I can go to just for some background information. And as awful as that may sound to some, I do enjoy the challenge of trying to figure stuff out with what resources I have available.
What I do not enjoy, however, is the constant stream of inefficiencies I have to deal with on a day-to-day basis. No two files ever seem to be organized the same way. In District Court, every file had a particular order and layout that made things very simple. If I needed a defendant’s history, I would go to the bottom of the left-hand side of the folder and look for the green sheets. Not so simple in Superior Court; apparently consistency is just so gauche. All sarcasm aside, it really is frustrating have to dig through piles upon piles of schedule settings and continuances just to find a damn police report (which is NEVER in the same place twice). If I had the time (and not so many case files), I would go through and systematically reorganize every file in my office. As it stands, though, I am lucky to even have my office organized in the way I want. And I cannot emphasize enough how accommodating my poor secretary has been; I know this must be just as hard for her as it is for me. I guess I should count my blessings.
Even more frustrating, however, is going through a case that you have never seen before, realizing that you have about a week to prepare yourself for the case’s next hearing (or trial), and then further realizing that certain key pieces of your case are missing. Today’s big discovery was a case I had never once set eyes on until this afternoon, set for trial in less than a week, everything in order (including subpoenas, which is a rare event in and of itself)…except for one crucial piece of discovery. And when I say crucial, I mean THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT PIECE OF EVIDENCE IN THE CASE WHICH I NEED TO ACTUALLY PROVE THE CASE.
Here is my long-winded explanation of why this is so damn infuriating. First and foremost, this case is a possession of methamphetamine charge. Possession cases are some of the most simple cases ever (either the defendant had the stuff in their possession, or they did not). Obviously, one of the key elements of such a charge is that the defendant actually had methamphetamine in their possession. And how do you prove that a particular substance is meth? Easy. You test it. In fact, that should probably be one of the first things you do. Then you present the lab results in your case, and the defendant gets to make up some excuse about why it was not his/her meth, and how they had absolutely no idea who’s meth it was.
Unfortunately for me, there was NO LAB REPORT in the file. And when I checked to see what might have happened to it, I found out that the meth NEVER GOT SENT TO THE LAB FOR TESTING IN THE FIRST PLACE. Had this case been charged a month or two ago, that might have made some sense; accidents happen, delays occur, and sometimes people just forget simple things. However, this particular case was charged OVER SIX MONTHS AGO. On top of that, the defense tried (and failed) to suppress the alleged meth on the theory that the police had issued a faulty search warrant! You would think that at some point, someone would have actually verified (beyond the field tests, which are inadmissible anyway) that the stuff was actually meth! But no…despite all the legal wrangling and other efforts put forth…the single most important, absolutely critical piece of evidence was left undiscovered…FOR SIX…EFFING…MONTHS. Try to wrap your brain around that one if you can.
tl;dr - Superior Court is definitely challenging…but for all the wrong reasons (right now, anyway).
Recent Comments